• Contact
  • Feedback
Banking Day
ConfidentiallySpeaking.com.au Logo
High-impact negotiation masterclass | July 9 & 16, 2025 | 5:00pm - 8:30pm
This high-impact negotiation masterclass teaches practical strategies to help you succeed in challenging negotiations.
Register Now
  • News
  • Topics
    • All Topics
    • Briefs
    • Major Banks
    • Authorised deposit-taking institutions
    • Insurance, funds and super
    • Payments, mobile & wallets
    • Consumer lending
    • Mortgages
    • Business lending
    • Finance regulation
    • Debt capital markets
    • Ratings agencies
    • Equity capital markets
    • Professional services
    • Work & career
    • Foreign news
    • Other topics
  • Free Trial
  • Subscribe
  • About us
    • About Banking Day
    • Advertise
    • Feedback
    • Contact Banking Day
  • Search
  • Login
  • My account
    • Account settings
    • User Admin
    • Logout

Login or request a free trial

CBA claims the grey area between misconduct and expectations

06 April 2018 5:00PM
The Commonwealth Bank, in its submission to the Royal Commission into banking misconduct, has challenged senior counsel assisting Rowena Orr on her definitions of "misconduct" and "conduct falling below community standards and expectations".CBA's response began with a defence of the commission structure that it has in place for mortgage brokers. The bank, while conceding that its broker commission structure is linked to the size of the loan, and this can lead to a conflict between the customer's interest and the broker's interest, went on to point out that any change away from commissions needed to be "industry wide". The bank also noted that if a loan application is approved the customer's loan documentation describes the amount of commission payable as "not ascertainable".CBA made a second point around its concern that the commission will make a finding that the manner in which it monitored the activities of head groups breached its obligations under the NCCP Act and the Corporations Act.In particular, CBA was keen to dispel any notion that it regarded any CBA-accredited broker as acting as its agent, despite the fact that an agreement between CBA and the head group described the head group as "our agent". CBA said this was only in relation to the head group's "completion and collection of customer identification tax file number disclosure privacy protection of information forms and any bank account opening application."The logic behind this was that any conflict of interest is limited to legal arrangements between customers and brokers not customers and the bank.CBA has therefore asked the commission to conclude the interposed step of a broker who is, nevertheless, authorised to submit a loan application does so acting as the agent of the customer not as agent of the lender. In this regard, the bank noted that all brokers and head groups were required to have their own ACL and brokers provide a "credit service" as defined in the NCCP Act.As a further exercise in finger-pointing CBA noted that it has in place controls "to ensure compliance by the head groups and its accredited mortgage brokers with CBA's Mortgage Broker Code of Conduct". The bank also asserted that internal audit reports pointing out weaknesses in its assessment of brokers did not amount to contraventions of the NCCP Act nor the corporations act as these were intended to identify areas where improvement could be made.CBA then went on to attack the third "alleged misconduct finding" which was that it breached its obligations under the NCCP Act or the Corporations Act by failing to disclose commissions paid to head groups. CBA's argument is that: "simply put, this is because brokers had the legal obligation to make these disclosures, while CBA had no such obligation."CBA also took the opportunity to argue that misconduct may be a legal term but "conduct falling below community standards and expectations conveys a breach of some general moral duty," and is "not reflected in any legal or professional norm".It was the bank's apparent contention that this term is so

I'm a returning subscriber

*
Password reset *
Login

Request a free trial

  • Emailing you the news at 7am.
  • Covering core lending and funding issues, strategy, payments, regulation, risk management, IT, marketing and more.
  • Original news and summaries of major stories from other media – ditch your newspaper subscriptions.
  • Focused on banking and finance, saving you the time spent wading through newspapers and other services.
  • With reporting from former editors and senior writers from the AFR and The Australian.
  • Configured for your phone, laptop and PC.
Free trial Banking Day
ConfidentiallySpeaking.com.au Logo
High-impact negotiation masterclass | July 9 & 16, 2025 | 5:00pm - 8:30pm
This high-impact negotiation masterclass teaches practical strategies to help you succeed in challenging negotiations.
Register Now

Finance regulation

  • States take up the cudgels on eConveyancing
  • Firstmac failed design and distribution rules
  • 'Minimal' bankruptcy reforms tabled by Dreyfus

Consumer lending

  • Latitude, Harvey Norman liable for interest free GO card con
  • Credit quality dogs Zip turnaround

Copyright © WorkDay Media 2003-2025.

Banking Day is a WorkDay Media publication

WorkDay Media Unit Trust

  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of access and use